13 November 2026
The Government has recently announced its plans to reduce the circumstances in which public bodies will need to carry out formal consultations, describing the current “consultation culture” as a source of “dither and delay”. This is part of a wider suite of reforms aimed at simplifying government and enhancing the accountability of ministers. Oliver Dickie, Ella Broadway, and Olivia Peake explain what you need to know.
In a letter dated 7 September 2026 addressed to government ministers, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, First Secretary of State and Attorney General set out their vision for simplifying government. They explained that they sought to reduce the “administrative frictions” delaying and frustrating government decision-making in three areas: consultations, judicial review and “legal considerations”.
Before considering the Government’s proposed consultation reforms, it is worth briefly considering their context. In recent years, both the UK’s laws and its courts have on occasions been accused of depriving politicians of powers they ought to be able to exercise. Most readers will be familiar with the scrutiny the courts came under for the decisions in Miller 1 and Miller 2, both judicial review challenges concerning the lawfulness of the government’s decisions in relation to the UK’s withdrawal from the European Union. Following Miller 1, the three judges who took the decision were notoriously described by the Daily Mail as “enemies of the people”.
Whilst the 7 September letter is couched in far more moderate language, the proposed reforms seem to be underpinned by the same concern: that legal requirements such as the duty to consult, and the courts which enforce them, unduly constrain ministers. They could be characterised as seeking to adjust the balance between the government and judiciary.
Status quo and proposed reforms
The 7 September letter criticised a culture of “dither and delay” which the Government attributes to consultations. The various obligations currently imposed on public authorities in relation to consultations can be summarised as follows:
- Where there is an obligation in statute to consult, public authorities must hold a consultation which complies with any associated statutory conditions and with the common law principles known as the Gunning principles, derived from the eponymous case (proposals must be at a formative stage, sufficient reasons must be provided to allow intelligent consideration, adequate time for consideration and response must be provided, and responses must receive conscientious consideration).
- Public authorities are also obliged to hold a public consultation compliant with the Gunning principles where (i) there has been a promise to consult or established practice of consultation; and (ii) in exceptional cases, a failure to consult would lead to conspicuous unfairness.
- If a public authority voluntarily chooses to consult, it must do so fairly, in accordance with the Gunning principles (R v North and East Devon Health Authority ex p Coughlan [2001] QB 213, at [108]).
- Public authorities are subject to various reporting duties in relation to the consultation document, responses, and decision.
The 7 September letter announced a two-pronged strategy for reforming consultations: paring back the requirement to consult where there has been a promise to consult or established practice of consultation, with the focus simply being “fairness”; and unwinding statutory consultation and reporting requirements. It is unclear when this second stage will commence; presumably not until the next parliamentary session at the earliest, since no mention of it was made in the latest King’s Speech back in May.
The letter also announced that the Government intended to update the Attorney General’s legal risk guidance to make clear that “it is wholly proper for ministers to take decisions where there is a tenable legal argument even where there is a high level of legal risk”, and to encourage lawyers to be more proactive in suggesting mitigations and alternatives. The legal risk guidance was promptly updated that week. Such expedition suggests that existing consultation guidance may also be updated swiftly.
Our thoughts
The proposals bring to the fore the (sometimes blurred) distinction between “formal” consultations (subject to the Gunning principles) and “informal” methods of engagement, the legal status and requirements of which are less clearcut. An example of the latter being the input sought from policing bodies on regulations to amend the Public Order Act 1986 in the Liberty case, which the Court of Appeal held was “a sensible, and necessary, attempt to obtain the views of the authorities responsible for imposing conditions on processions and assemblies”, rather than a formal consultation requiring a representative range of consultees. The intention appears to be to reduce the former in favour of the latter.
The proposals have sparked a mixed reaction. Critics argue that reducing the use of formal consultations may lead to policies being developed without adequate public input, potentially undermining their fairness, practicality and effectiveness. It might also be said that the proposal to pare back the use of consultations where there has been a promise to consult or established practice of consultation sits uncomfortably with the importance of the government being seen to keep its promises and behave predictably, particularly where vulnerable individuals or groups are disproportionately impacted.
That said, it seems fair to say that “box-ticking” consultation does not benefit anyone. The proposals could be characterised as a shift in the method of engagement, rather than the wholesale removal of opportunities for public input. The Government is not proposing to prevent public bodies and departments from engaging with the public or relevant industries. Instead, it proposes a more “participatory policymaking approach”. The letter suggests that this may involve a range of people contributing to policy development at an earlier stage and through more direct forms of engagement.
This seems to demonstrate an aspiration that the method of engagement should depend on its purpose: (a) obtaining the specialist expertise required to make an effective decision – as in the Liberty case; and/or (b) the need to confer legitimacy on a divisive decision (an example being the Government’s recent consultation on whether to ban social media for under-sixteens, which it described as allowing “voices on all sides to be heard” on an issue attracting “deeply held, often conflicting, views”).
It remains to be seen what challenges may arise in the coming months, particularly in areas such as tax, employment and immigration law, where the law is complex and policy often benefits from multiple perspectives if it is to work as intended from the outset. Decisions in these areas may also directly affect the public, particularly taxpayers.
The reforms may have little impact initially. The proposed changes will require reviewing and amending the statute book, a time-consuming exercise. Such changes did not feature in the parliamentary timetable in the latest King’s Speech. Furthermore, the mooted updates to various guidance will not have an impact overnight. They aim principally to alter the approach of decision-makers, as well as that of the civil service and lawyers advising the Government. It is likely that the sought-for change in culture will take time to embed and that, in trying to remedy perceived obstructions to decision-making, others may be identified.
The proposals are at a formative stage, however, and will no doubt develop in the coming months. We may ultimately be at the start of a long process of reform.
Sharpe Pritchard is experienced at advising on consultations, including disputes arising from alleged failures to consult and/or the conduct of consultations. Please do not hesitate to contact us if we can be of assistance.